Deer are beautiful animals and seeing them strolling or jumping around out in the woods can be a real picturesque sight. You might admire them when you see them come near your garden at first; carefully approaching, so you don’t scare them off, trying to make friends with them.
Then they start munching on your plants on the regular and now you yell and cuss at them every time you lay eyes upon them. Still, they keep coming back and ruining all your hard work – no fence can keep them out, and no alarm can scare them off.
We know that feeling very well, and that’s why we wrote this article, to present you with a clean, cheap and easy way to get rid of them – deer repellents. The best deer repellents can get rid of your deer problem in just one spray, and this article contains just that – some of the best products on the market, directly compared. It’s up you to choose the one you’ll get.
Why Buying a Deer Repellent?
Some people might think they have a handle on things and their fence will keep their garden safe, or maybe some safety device they are using will do the job. Well, they are usually wrong – in our experience, each of those solutions fails sooner or later, leaving your garden ripe for the picking.
The best deer repellent in our opinion is the kind that comes in spray form. There are a few reasons for that, and first and foremost is that it’s just the cheapest way – electric or spiked fences cost a lot, as do the motion-detector equipped sprayers or loud alarms. Despite costing that much, all of those methods are not guaranteed to work. Deer repellent sprays have a higher success rate as they are based on simple logic – coat the plants in smells and tastes that deer highly dislike, and they will naturally stay away from them.
Some sprays are made from natural, recycled materials, like rotten eggs and fish meal and the like, while some use specially made chemicals to achieve their results. Any way you slice it, these sprays are the most effective tools for keeping deer away and at a low price. You just have to make sure that they don’t cause more trouble than they’re worth.
What we mean by that is that you should make sure they keep deer away but don’t pose any trouble for your animals, plants or you and other people. Because of this, you have to be careful when picking out the right deer repellent spray and that can be difficult. To help you with that, we gathered the best current products we could find and directly compared them to each other. To help you further we offer some of our opinions on them, as well as user opinions. With that in mind, let’s take a look at our top picks.
Meet the Best Deer Repellents
The Good: Natural, long-lasting, safe and smells nice – it’s good in almost every area.
The Bad: It doesn’t keep other animals away.
The Bottom Line: It keeps the deer away, just as advertised while having practically no flaws to speak of.
The Good: It’s extremely effective at keeping deer away for a long time.
The Bad: Not very water resistant and has a nasty smell.
The Bottom Line: While it is great at repelling deer, it might not last for a long time due to poor rain resistance.
The Good: Natural and safe for animals, water resistant and ready to use in a sprayer.
The Bad: It isn’t safe for your edibles and smells terrible.
The Bottom Line: It does its job at keeping away deer, but its pungent odor is irritating to humans as well. Not sufficiently safe either.
This is just an overview of the more detailed information that is contained in the article below.
All of the Factors Considered
Deer repellents might seem like simple products – they either keep deer out, or they don’t, and that’s all there is to it, right? Wrong. That’s just the start, and there are plenty of other things that make a deer repellent good or bad. Because of that, choosing the right one for you might be exceptionally tricky – but we’re willing to help. Here are some of the most important aspects to consider when it comes to deer repellents.
This is the area you can cover with a certain amount of spray – usually the amount that comes in the bottle, though some may list it as coverage per gallon, and you should be mindful of that when checking the label.
How much ground a bottle of deer repellent spray can cover is important since you don’t want to make a mistake like buying a large amount of cheap spray that can only cover a small area.
Consider your needs, your budget, always look at the label and pick accordingly.
Of course, you don’t want your deer repellent spray to get washed out by the first rain – you want it to last. Moreover, you need to water your plants on the regular, and spraying them after each time would be quite the chore. Thus, you should pick a spray that has adequate rain and water resistance so it can last through all of that.
Once you spray your plants and fences with the deer repellent what you want it to do is to keep deer away, of course. However, you don’t want to hurt or drive away your animals with the spray. You also don’t want to contaminate your garden plants, especially if you intend on eating them or letting your animals eat them. So, how safe a spray is for both animals and humans other than deer is an important factor.
Depending on what it’s made of, deer repellent sprays can smell a lot, and it can be so overpowering that you will have to wear a protective mask while applying them, not only for your mouth and nose but also for your eyes. This smell usually dissipates with time, but you should pick one that doesn’t last for too much time as you don’t want your garden to smell like a garbage heap.
Luckily there are also deer repellents made out of materials that smell nice to humans, like peppermint or cinnamon for example, but smell rancid to deer, thus driving them away. These repellents may not be as effective as some of the more foul-smelling ones, but they might be a good choice if you don’t want the smell to drive away humans and deer alike.
So, now that we outline all the important aspects of deer repellents, it’s time to rank the ones we picked.
In-depth Reviews of 3 Deer Repellents
Made from completely natural ingredients, ensuring that it’s safe not only for any pets or animals you might have but also for you. Any fruit or vegetable treated with this product is completely safe for consumption, no need to worry.
Even heavy rains shouldn’t wash this deer repellent off, and it can last for upwards of three or four months. You can also water your plants regularly without any fears of it coming off, so you don’t need to reapply
This 32-ounce bottle of concentrated solution o can be diluted and used to cover almost ten thousand square feet of ground, allowing for repeated use over a long period, even if you have a larger yard.
No stink coming from this one – this deer repellent only smells bad to animals. As far as you and others are concerned, it smells minty and fresh for days. No need to wear a mask or keep away from your garden for days after spraying.
Who Should Buy This Product
This product is suitable for almost anyone. People with huge yards will find it able to cover their entire property, while people with smaller yards will get years of use out of it. It doesn’t cost a lot either and doesn’t produce any rancid smells meaning that people who have a problem with that won’t have an issue with this product. In addition to all that, it’s completely natural and perfectly safe.
What to Watch Out For
The only major problem with this product is that it is just what it says on the box – a deer repellent. Some spray repellents deter other animals as well, like rabbits or squirrels, but this one does not, leading to people thinking that it doesn’t work very well when it does exactly what it’s supposed to do and nothing more.
Overall, this is a great product for the price, and you’ll get plenty of use out of it. It keeps deer away just as advertised while leaving your garden with a fresh minty smell instead of a pungent odor. It doesn’t get washed out by water, and it’s perfectly safe for both you and any pets you might have since it’s completely natural. The only downside is that it doesn’t work on other animals – but it’s not supposed to, anyway.
With a bottle of this you will be able to cover almost a whole ten thousand square feet of ground, meaning that it will last you for many seasons even if you have a large property to protect.
In ideal conditions, one application should be able to last you for a full foraging cycle and beyond. There are no problems with it getting washed out by regular watering of the plants and it rarely needs to be reapplied.
Any animals you might have, whether they be farm animals or pets, should be completely safe around this product. Deer will not even come close to it, but other animals will be completely fine.
While the scent of this product is strong it should dissipate in a matter of hours, leaving your yard completely smell-free, while still being smelly enough to keep the deer away.
Who Should Buy This Product
For people who need to make sure the deer stay very far away from their yard and garden, this product is ideal as it is incredibly effective at repelling deer. They will hesitate to even come at a hundred feet from it, let alone any closer. You will have no worries about them trashing your garden.
What to Watch Out For
The problem here is that the water resistance, while fine for things like watering the plants and such, is not adequate for any heavier rain. Even when copiously applied, it can still get washed away in harsh weather, and if you live in rainy areas, you will need to reapply it a lot.
This product is more than effective at keeping deer away from any place where it is applied, and it can cover a huge area, but there are a few problems with it. The most important one is the fact that it does not stand up well to rain, meaning that you will need to reapply it often. When that is considered, it might last for a shorter time than you might think at first. Still a quality product, just a bit flawed.
With a single, ready-to-use sprayer bottle containing 32 ounces of spray you can cover up to a thousand square feet of ground, meaning you will get a lot of use. All of that at a poultry price that’s only a fraction of the one that similar products charge.
Made from Natural Ingredients
The mixture of this deer repellent uses only natural ingredients – meaning that it is completely safe for animals, humans and other living creatures. It repels deer, and it even does that without harming or poisoning them.
Readily Diluted in Water
As it is already diluted in water, this deer repellent will not wash off when you water your plants or when it rains, meaning that it will stay effective for a long time and you will not need to waste it by reapplying it all the time.
The Smell Goes Away
While incredibly smelly, this product is made in such a way that the smell disappears quickly after use, as far as humans are concerned, but stays present for deer and other animals that might get a whiff of it.
Who Should Buy This Product
For people who want a ready-to-use deer repellent in a spray, without needing to prepare a mixture, this is the right product. It also works great for people on a budget as it is incredibly inexpensive, but still does its job very well, making sure that deer stay far away from your land.
What to Watch Out For
The incredibly strong smell of this product is undeniable, and it lasts for quite a long time when there’s no wind around. When spraying it you’ll need some serious protection for your eyes, nose, and mouth, and if you get it on yourself it will be hard to wash out, so be careful when using it.
It does keep the deer away really good and at an incredibly affordable price, which might make you think “what’s the catch?” – And there is one. The smell is just incredibly bad and doesn’t go away very fast. This makes it a hard deal – but if you can tolerate the stench, it does what it’s supposed to do, and it offers great value for the money.
The Best Pick – Deer Out
There are plenty of different deer repellents out there and choosing just one can seem like an insurmountable task. However, we think we got it, as for us the best deer repellent out there is most certainly Deer Out. The reason for that is simple – it offers almost everything you could look for in a deer repellent spray while having no obvious downsides to it. Compared to the other products, which have at least one glaring flaw, this is almost the perfect thing for anyone looking to keep some deer out of their garden.
Deer Out is our top pick, but that doesn’t mean the other products we listed here are bad – on the contrary, they are all top-of-the-line, and there’s a good reason we mentioned them. Some of them might be the right deer repellent for you and your garden. You should look at all the available options and choose wisely.
For now, we just hope this article helped you make that choice, and if it did, please feel free to share it with other people who need this kind of help. Have a good day, and we hope your yard stays deer-free!