The Best Compost Tumbler Reviews in 2020 – Turn Waste into Gold

Here at Homyden, our editors independently research, test and recommend the best products. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases made from our chosen links, there is no additional cost to you.

When gardening, compost is a necessity that helps keep your plants well-fed and healthy. However, it is also expensive, which is why some people skim on it. On the other hand, gardening also produces a lot of plant waste that you can’t just leave lying around, and most people just collect it all and send it to the landfill.

But why would you do that, when you can just use a composter and kill two birds with one stone? With the best compost tumbler, you can turn all your waste into black gold that you can use to feed your plants and save yourself a lot of trouble and money. It’s a win-win deal.

In this article, we’ll go over why a compost tumbler is such a game-changer when it comes to gardening, and we’ll provide you with an overview of the best products on the market right now.

Why Buying a Compost Tumbler?

Now, most of you probably know why compost is important. Some of you might even be using your waste to make it already, piling it up in the open or inside bins, waiting for it to decompose and turn into the valuable substance that your plants require. However, those are rather inefficient methods that only prolong the time needed to get there – using a compost tumbler is better for a few different reasons.

Compost Tumbler

Turn waste into gold with the best compost tumbler

For starters, it just makes the whole process a lot less messy. The piles, as they get bigger, also get unsightly – they start to smell terrible and spread that smell to the entire surrounding area while attracting a lot of nasty insects and other pests that come to feast on the decomposing matter. Some people with weaker stomachs might not be able to handle it. Compost tumblers get rid of all that, as they keep the pests out while keeping the odor in.

You might think that compost bins do the same, and yes they do, but there’s a key difference between compost bins and compost tumblers. Turning the piles of compost over as they get bigger and heftier can become a real chore. With a compost tumbler, this is as easy as turning a crank a couple of times, unlike a compost bin where you still have to do it by hand.

The most important part, probably, is that it makes the whole process faster. Keeping all the waste in a contained space allows it to heat up better and degrade quicker, while the ability to turn it and mix it easily speeds up the process as well. It’s just good stuff all around.

However, not all compost tumblers are the same, and some are just flat-out better than others, while some are almost useless. Nabbing a good one when going shopping can be difficult, but that’s why we wrote this article – to assist you with that. We’ve gathered some of the best products out there today, compared them to each other and added some user reviews as well, for added info. This should help you spot a best composting tumbler when you see one. Let’s look at our top picks right now.

Meet the Best Compost Tumblers

IM4000 Dual Chamber Tumbling Composter (Black)

The Good: It offers decent capacity, good durability and has a great design.

The Bad: It’s extremely difficult to assemble, and the instructions are bad.

The Bottom Line: This tumbler is difficult to assemble, but if you can get past that, you get a great composter for an amazing price.

No products found.

Good Ideas CW-2X12 Senior Wizard Dual Tumbler Compost Bin

The Good: Amazing capacity – this tumbler features two chambers for compost.

The Bad: Heavy to use and operate, expensive, and not easy to get the compost out.

The Bottom Line: This tumbler is huge, but its capacity and double chamber still don’t justify its price.

This is just a quick overview – for detailed info, head on down below.

All of the Factors Considered

Compost tumblers might seem rather simple, which is why it might be hard to notice the difference between the best compost tumbler and a rubbish one before you even buy it. Picking the right one for you and not a useless piece of trash is important, so we are here to help. These are the most important aspects you should consider when buying a compost tumbler, and the reasons why you should be looking at them.


Since composters are machines meant to be used for a long time and stay outdoors, it’s paramount they are made of sturdy materials that can withstand a lot of punishment. This is doubly important for compost tumblers which have a lot of moving parts that can easily break under the weight of the compost. Getting a cheaper compost tumbler might seem good at first, but if it breaks rather quickly and you have to buy a new one before you get even one batch of compost done with it, you have just wasted your money. Don’t be afraid to pay extra for a quality-built unit – you’ll need it.


Compost tumblers come in a few differing types, each with its unique features:

Sealed drum compost tumblers, as their name says, are completely sealed, allowing no moisture to drain from them, and they hold in heat to make the process quicker. It can also be equipped with a drain to draw off the “compost tea” that forms and that can be used as fertilizer down the line. They work slower than some other types though.

Aerated drum composters contain built-in air vents, as good air flow speeds up the decomposing process. The air vents can be different in shape and size, some even being spike-shaped, working to bring the air to the center of the compost heap inside the drum. They are usually smaller than other types because they work faster.

Dual-bin types are ingenious in their design. They have two chambers that can be rotated together and they are thickly insulated, keeping the heat in and speeding up the decomposition process. But, they also contain openings that can provide aeration, if opened. The best part here is that you can have almost finished compost in one chamber, while adding new waste to the other, being able to have two piles decomposing without having to buy an additional composter.

Best Compost Tumbler

Each type has unique features

You should look at the upsides and downsides of each type carefully, before making your final decision.


The capacity of a compost tumbler is important for obvious reasons – the more compost you can put into it, the more use you can get out of it. However, bigger isn’t always better, especially if you don’t have a lot of material to make compost with. In that case, getting a big composter can be a downside, since if the material is too loose and not packed tightly enough, it will take a longer time for it to decompose properly and turn into compost. So, consider how much material you would use with it and pick accordingly.

Be aware – when it comes to Dual-bin type, the capacity refers to both compartments combined. Take that into account when buying one.

Ease of Use

Compost tumblers are meant to make your job easier and to make composting faster. Being easy and effortless to use is a big selling point, and if it’s not, there’s not much point to it. So, it’s important how easy a compost tumbler is to turn while full or nearly full; does it comes with a stand that it can be put on or do you have to find a place for it; how big are its doors and how well placed they are so you can quickly fill it up, and so on.

After listing all the important aspects, let’s see how we ranked our top picks.

In-depth Reviews of 3 Best Compost Tumblers

Yimby Tumbler Composter

The thing that stands out about this product is the price – it’s incredibly low for a compost tumbler like this one, leading to doubts when it comes to its quality. It dispels those doubts with ease, being great in almost every aspect. That is if you can manage to assemble it.
Ease of Use100
What We Like
Has an extremely low price
Dual-bin design
Made from durable materials
What We Don't Like
Difficult to assemble
Water gets into the compost chamber

Key Features

Durable Construction

With a body made from recycled polypropylene and a sturdy steel frame, this composter is guaranteed to last. The plastic is UV inhibited and resistant to damage from direct sunlight, while the galvanized steel is not prone to corrosion.

Two-chambered Tumbling Composter

Having two chambers means you can have one side that is finishing cooking while adding fresh materials to the other, meaning you don’t have to wait for one batch to finish to start another one or buy multiple composters. You can simply have an uninterrupted supply of rich compost for your garden.

Great Capacity

The amazing capacity of this compost tumbler, measuring 37 gallons, ensures that it will always be spacious enough to take in all the waste you might want to put into it.

Easy to Turn

Using this is simple, and it requires turning only a few times every few days, which you can do using convenient built-in handholds. It has its own frame meaning it doesn’t need to be put in an elevated position. It has one sliding door for both compartments. It’s also aerated with adjustable air vents all over the body.

Customer Reviews

While the assembly instructions are poor, both on the web page and in the manual, you should be able to figure out what to do fairly easy. I did and got it assembled rather quickly, in a bit over an hour.

As for the quality of the product once assembled – it’s great so far. It takes me somewhere around two weeks to fill up the indoor bin before I have to start filling the tumbler. It decomposes faster than it did in the previous composter that I used, and I think I’ll have completely ready compost soon.

You have to assemble this unit before you can use it, it came in pieces. I like doing that, building stuff that is, so I didn’t mind the assembly process, but some might. It comes with rather unclear instructions, but it shouldn’t be hard to figure it out. So far, I am more than thrilled with it – it’s easy to use, even my daughter is helping me, and the two-chamber design seems much better than the usual design, like the previous composter I had. I put it in a sunny spot, to help with the process and I didn’t mind doing that since it looks good on my lawn. Overall, it seems great, and when I get some finished compost out of it, I’ll check back here to add more to my review.
I started dabbling in backyard composting, so I bought this tumbler purely based on the reviews for it. I have a relatively small backyard, and the neighbors are close to it, so I wanted a product that would keep various pests out and the smells in. Previously I used some large, old pots, but it was difficult to mix, and different pests kept messing with it. As others have said, this thing comes in parts and has approximately a hundred screws. Despite that, I found the assembly to be rather easy, I did it alone in a little over an hour, but you do have to know what you’re doing.

So far, it’s done a bang-up job of keeping the smells in so my neighbors aren’t annoyed, and it’s completely critter-proof. Everything is decomposing properly as well, and it’s easy to use, so much so that my children can help me with it.

Who Should Buy this Product

This tumbler is great for people who are on a budget and looking for a cheap, yet effective and quality alternative to more expensive products. It offers decent capacity, handy two-chamber aerated design and is made from quality, durable parts, meaning that it will last.

What to Watch Out For

The worst part about this product is the assembly process. It has a lot of parts, and the instructions aren’t helpful, meaning you will have to figure out most of it yourself, and that might take a lot of time. If you’re not extra careful, you might even break something and end up with a worthless pile of parts instead of a compost tumbler.

The Conclusion

This is just an overall good product, offering great specs for an affordable price. The capacity is decent, and it has a great two-chamber design with adjustable air flow to the inside of the tumbler. It’s easy to turn and made from durable materials. The only problem is that it comes in pieces and it is extremely difficult to assemble. It’s still a great product, but you need to get through that hurdle to start using it.

Purchase this Product on

Envirocycle Tumbler Composter

Here we have a rather expensive, but good product that has decent capacity, great durability and some awesome design decisions that make it easy to use. However, its design is not perfect, and there are flaws that begin to show when you start using it.
Ease of Use90
What We Like
No assembly needed
Easy to roll
Doesn’t break easily
What We Don't Like
The drain is badly placed
Difficult to close

Key Features

Solid Construction

This compost tumbler is constructed from materials that are resistant to rust, protected from UV damage and food safe. It’s made to withstand harsh conditions for years on end, meaning that you will get a lot of good use out of it.

35-gallon Capacity

That much capacity ensures that this compost tumbler will be able to take in whatever you need and keep having space. You will be able to make tons of compost in almost no time at all.

Produces Solid & Liquid Compost

With a solid, sealed drum and five drainage holes in the bottom of it, this compost tumbler can produce great solid compost. It also has a compost tea maker in the base, collecting excess liquid for fertilizing.

Simple to Use

It’s easy to turn because of the grooves on the surface of the drum while fitting nicely in a plastic podium. It has a large door, meaning you can put tons of waste in it at once for easy composting.

Customer Reviews

I completely adore this item, and I’m saving money to buy a second one as well. I need one for new compost while the other is still ‘cooking’ the compost in it. I only regret that I didn’t use the more brown material in it since the green gunk sticks to the sides and thuds against the walls too much while I turn it. I should be shredding some documents and adding that to it to break it all up, hopefully. If anybody has advice on that – please contact me. I have been composting either in or on the ground for years, but I’ve never used a tumbler before.
It’s simple to use and made to last for a long time – by far it’s the best I’ve had the pleasure of using to date. I have two of them so I’m able to alternate between them, which works well for me. You should put them up on some cinders blocks or something so you can put a bucket underneath the drain. There’s only one big problem with it, and that is the design flaw in the drain – the one on the front of it is halfway up the side and not at the bottom. That means you have to remove the barrel then tilt the base so you could drain it, which involves a lot of work since it can be extremely heavy. The worst part, though, is that it’s only slightly above the holes where the excess water drains into the base from the barrel, so it’s almost always nearly overflowing unless you drain it by tilting. That also means the base rapidly overflows if left out in the rain and all the compost tea is flushed away.
I’m just in love with this composter it’s so durable and easy to use. It wasn’t packed well when it arrived, so I was concerned, but what I opened the box it turned out it was fine. What keeps me from rating it a full five stars is that I want it to make compost tea for me, but every time it rains the water gets under it and fills the tea catcher up. After that, it backs up into the main body of the composter, so I have to drain the water constantly while getting no compost tea. That is frustrating, but in all other aspects, it performs well.

Who Should Buy this Product

This is a durable piece of kit with great capacity that will be fit for homeowners with a medium amount of waste that they could turn into compost. With something like this they won’t have any problems getting it done even if they are new to making compost. For beginners, this is a godsend.

What to Watch Out For

There are some design flaws that honestly should have been ironed out before mass production, but here we are. The biggest problem is the lid – it is difficult to close, and even when you might think you have it closed it could be slightly open. This means that the smells will get out, while the pests will be able to get in. You might not notice it right away, but you will in time.

The Conclusion

This compost tumbler is rather decent for lighter use at home, and it features a design that makes it easy to use, but also highly durable. It also looks nice, which is a nice bonus. However, it is expensive, especially for its size and has a host of design flaws that could have long-lasting consequences on its performance. It’s still a fine product, but that’s something to consider.

Purchase this Product on

Good Ideas CW-2X

This is a simply massive compost tumbler that has not one but two chambers, making it able to churn out compost for you at all times and almost never get filled up to the top. The reason why it doesn’t justify its high price is the fact that it’s a bit difficult to use and lacks some extra features.
Ease of Use80
What We Like
Massive capacity
Large lids and openings
Two chambers
What We Don't Like
Difficult to remove the compost from it
No compost tea collector
Hard to turn

Key Features

Made to Last

Created from recycled polyethylene, resistant to damage from UV rays and with dense walls that can’t be broken through easily. It can do its work and last for years on end, through any abuse or harsh weather.

Incredible Capacity

This composter features an astounding capacity of 82 gallons or 11 cubic feet. With that much space, it’s almost impossible to run out, and you will be able to create a massive amount of compost with this unit.

Dual-bin Design

With a sealed dual-bin design and two massive bins, this compost tumbler is sure to ease your work and make compost in no time. With two chambers you will never have to stop creating compost or buy another composter – just get a steady stream of that black gold for your garden.

Convenient Construction

The large openings and lids are made so that animals and children can get into the bin and the odor can’t get out. Massive grab bars on the barrel are designed to make it easy to grip and turn.

Customer Reviews

I bought it to handle all the waste from my guinea pigs and rabbits. We use no bedding but have half a dozen litter boxes with paper litter. We also have plenty of straw and other plant matter that we put into the composter.

I have been using it for a little more than five weeks now, and the side I filled up to the brim is almost complete. The other side is filled up and somewhat decomposed.

I expected unpleasant odors to come from this, but it’s rather good on that front. I plan to order another one soon since I have plenty of materials and I refuse to send it to the landfill when it makes for nice compost. I’ve spent a lot of money for compost bags, but with these, I won’t have to.

The only problem I have with it is that the doors are rather small so I use a scoop and a smaller shovel to fit everything in.

I never had a composter before this, nor have I ever tried my hand at making compost for myself. The things I like the most is that it can do two batches at one time, it works pretty well. I used it to make a batch of soil for potting, and it’s amazing. The only issue I have with it are the openings, they are difficult to open and are pretty small. Still a decent product though.
I bought it to make compost faster and make my life easier, but I’ve had mixed results. It works for sure, even though it doesn’t seem that great, the compost doesn’t get made much faster than normal. It can also be a bit of a pain to turn when it’s completely filled up. I guess it’s fine, in the end, but I had higher expectations for it.

Who Should Buy this Product

People who have a huge amount of waste they want to turn into compost and don’t want to buy multiple composters to do it should look at this product. It not only has a massive capacity it has two chambers meaning that it’s like two units in one, always making compost for you.

What to Watch Out For

The problem with its massive size is that it’s difficult to turn even when only half full, and its design doesn’t help at all. The massive grip bars are hard to get a hold of, and a lot of strength is required to turn it even when you do. In addition to that, it also lacks a compost tea collector, meaning all of that is going to waste and your compost might be a soggy mess inside.

The Conclusion

It does offer a lot of things that other similar products do not, and is especially notable for its huge capacity that seems almost unrivaled. However, it is expensive, difficult to use and lacks a lot of the extra features that make compost tumblers so useful. With that in mind, it’s difficult to recommend, even though it has some great specs.

Purchase this Product on

The Best Compost Tumbler – Yimby Tumbling Composter

There are plenty of compost tumbler models out there, more than we can count, and each one offers something slightly different than the others, making them a good fit for different people. Picking just one as the best one is difficult – but not impossible. For us, the best one is the Yimby Tumbling Composter, and here’s why. It’s just the best value for the money – while other models presented here offer some neat features, they are just incredibly expensive, and the Yimby product offers comparable quality at a much lower price. It’s just a no-contest, it wins hands-down.

The Conclusion

That is our best pick, but it doesn’t mean the other products in this article are not worth buying – far from it, they are all top quality products, and some of them might even fit you well. It’s up to you to decide, and we can just hope our article was at least of some help to you when it comes to that. If you think there are others who might find all this information useful, please, share this article with them. Have a good day and good luck composting.


  1. Tom Esthber July 11, 2019
  2. Brian Pratt July 12, 2019
  3. Roy July 12, 2019
  4. Meg W July 12, 2019
  5. Patricia July 12, 2019
  6. Maury Cheskes July 12, 2019
  7. Quentin August 21, 2019
  8. Jonathan Kelly August 21, 2019
  9. Rosemary August 24, 2019
  10. Charlie September 2, 2019
  11. Gabriel March 19, 2020
  12. Henry March 27, 2020

Leave a Reply