The Best Weed Killer Reviews in 2018 – Make Sure Weeds Die and Stay Dead

Gardening can be a lot of hard work even if you have a small property. Still, I don’t mind doing most of it if it ensures my plants are healthy – I even find it pleasurable. However, the one chore I don’t take any joy in is weeding. Pulling weeds is tricky and can take up a lot of time since you need to be very careful not to damage the roots of your precious plants while pulling the entire weed out. And yet, even after all that work, weeds will just spring up again in a couple of weeks, so it all seems futile.

Well, that’s why I gave up on it and took the easy route years ago – a chemical weed killer. Still, a lot of people don’t use them for some reason, and that’s why I wrote this article – to introduce people to these products and help them find the best weed killer for their garden.

Why Buying a Weed Killer?

So, as I mentioned, some people still stick to the traditional methods of just pulling the weeds out of the ground by hand. There are those who think it is the best method for removing weeds from your crop.

The problem with this approach, besides the fact that it can damage the plants you want growing in your garden, is that it’s not a final solution – weeds will spring up again and again. Over time, weed growth will damage your plants, whether by depriving them of nutrients, letting some pests settle in the garden or by transmitting some nasty disease.

Weed killers, or weedicides as they’re also known, are a type of herbicide specially designed to kill weeds and stop them from growing in your garden again. Some target a broad range of weeds, while others are far more specific. No matter the type, they are made from a variety of different chemicals, some designed to poison the weeds while others might imitate an anti-growth hormone.

Spray Weeding

Weed Killers Kill Weeds and Stop them from Growing in Your Garden Again

So, not all weed killers are the same, and there’s a lot of variety. If you pick the wrong one, it might not even work or, worse yet, kill your plants while leaving the weeds alive and well. Choosing the right compound for the job is paramount, and there’s plenty of aspects to consider. To help you with picking, we have compiled a list of some of the best weed killers out there right now, paired with some user reviews for added info. Let’s see how the three products fare.

Meet the Best Weed Killers

Sale
Compare-N-Save Concentrate Grass and Weed Killer, 41-Percent Glyphosate, 1-Gallon

The Good: Kills any weed you might have and can cover a vast area.

The Bad: Isn’t easy to use and doesn’t prevent weeds from regrowing, and it takes some time to work.

The Bottom Line: While it has some obvious flaws, it’s still the best bang for your buck.

This is not everything of course – more in-depth info is available just down below.

All of the Factors Considered

When buying a weed killer, there are more than a few things you need to consider before making your purchase. The choices on offer might make you feel confused, but don’t worry – follow some of the tips here, and you should probably be fine.

Water Resistance

Picking a weed killer with sufficient water resistance is key, as you do not want it to get washed away with the first rain, or when you’re just watering the plants. The quicker the resistance kicks in, the better.

Selectiveness

Selective weed killers are usually designed to get rid of one particular plant species or plant genus. Some have a broader range than others, and it’s important to know which types of plants they’ll destroy, so you don’t ruin your garden by accident while trying to save it.

Non-selective weed killers exist as well and they usually just kill all or most plants they come into contact with. This means they can’t be used on surfaces like lawns and must be applied very precisely. However, they can be more effective than selective products.

Speed

The rate at which a weed killer acts roughly divides them into contact and systemic weed killers.

Contact weed killers kill the plant almost instantly, and you only have to wait a few minutes to see the grass wither before your eyes. However, they can be only used on plants that have already grown and, while they look impressive, they are not good in the long run and might leave the roots intact.

Systemic weed killers, on the other hand, do a much more thorough job of massacring the plant from the inside. They get in through the leaves and spread down to the roots, killing the whole thing. It takes them more time to eliminate the weed, but that ensures that it won’t rise from the dead.

Longevity

While weed killers are certainly better at eliminating weeds than the traditional method, their effects do not last forever, and weeds will reappear in time. How long – that depends on the compound that was used. While some weed killers are a one-and-done deal and just kill plants, others leave a residual effect that can prevent them from re-growing for weeks or months at a time.

Safety

If you own pets or livestock, this is paramount, as the chemicals might be poisonous to them, and they might accidentally ingest it in various ways. The ‘pet-friendly’ kinds of weed killers ensure that such a scenario doesn’t occur and your animals stay safe and healthy.

The other important safety consideration is that it does not harm the plants in your garden in any way and kills only the weeds. Destroying your whole garden is not what you want.

Based on all these aspects, here’s how we’d rank all the products we listed.

In-depth Reviews of 3 Weed Killers

Compare-N-Save Concentrate Grass and Weed Killer
Summary
The first thing that's noticeable about this product is the high glyphosate concentration it has, which ensures that any and all weeds are killed, and it can be applied to a massive area. While it kills the weeds, it also guarantees the safety of your plants by not leaving any active compounds in the soil. However, that very property might be the biggest problem it has.
Water Resistance90
Selectiveness95
Speed85
Longevity85
Safety90
What We Like
Can cover a huge area
Minimal risk for your plants
41% glyphosate concentration
Covers up to 45.000 square feet
What We Don't Like
Not safe for pets or livestock
Offers no further protection from new growths
Requires mixing before use
89
Great

Key Features

Rainproof Within Two Hours

Only two hours after spraying, this product is completely water resistant. Rain or shine, it works just the same!

Visible Results in Two to Four Days

With a 41-percent glyphosate compound, the weeds die within a few days while being killed to the root, never to return.

No Residual Effects

Since this is a post-emergent product, treated areas can be replanted within one day with no risk – this weed killer leaves no activity in the soil after doing its job.

Kills any Weeds, anywhere

It’s non-selective and can be used on pretty much any weed without issue, it will kill them all without prejudice – something we’re very proud of.

Customer Reviews

I applied this product as recommended on my lot (half an acre in size) and it worked like a charm. Plenty of weeds grew out over time due to me not maintaining my yard like I used to. I was completely frustrated and just wanted to start from scratch, and that’s what I used this product for. It took a couple of days for the results to show, and they were significant! The weeds and grass looked like a forest fire ran trough them. My whole yard was completely brown. I wait a few weeks prior to aerating and then reseeding, and now my yard is back to being the envy of my neighbors! I give this product a full five stars, and for this price, you really can't go wrong.
Epic stuff here, the best you can get for your money. This stuff just slays everything.

I used the same product last year, and it worked like you wouldn’t believe. It doesn’t last for the whole year; you'll probably have to apply it once more after a couple of months have passed. Also, some plants are more resilient, and it won't work on them so quickly. The grass growing in my driveway took almost an entire week to dry out while other weeds around the yard and house were brown a few hours after I sprayed them. Have no fear though – if you use this on a plant, it will die for sure.

It's not a lie that it will take some time for this weed killer to work, sometimes even a few weeks. Still, if you have some patience, this product is more than worth it, and it's cheaper than similar ones. I use it for spraying my fence perimeter and the weeds that occasionally appear on my driveway. I expect the bottle will last me a good seven to eight years. I did spray lightly around my fence perimeter in a single-pass, and some weeks later almost one foot of grass along the fence had dried out. I believe it doesn't break down quickly and stays in the soil for a long time, so rain washed it out. In that sense, a little bit of this product can do a lot of work for you.

Who Should Buy This Product

People with larger properties should look out for this one, as that one gallon can cover a huge area, up to 25 thousand square feet. The fact that it kills basically any weeds you could find on a large surface – and you can find plenty of different kinds – makes it very useful indeed.

What to Watch Out For

Even though it kills weeds for sure, it will not prevent new ones from appearing on your property I’m sad to say. If that’s what you’re looking for, this is not the product for you.

The Conclusion

Being able to kill any and all weeds you can find over a large surface is a great feat, and this product achieves it effortlessly. The fact that it doesn’t cost all that much makes it even more attractive, even though it has some downsides, and won’t prevent weed growth. In short, if you’re looking for destruction, this is what you should buy – if you’re looking for prevention, stay away.

Roundup 5200210 Weed and Grass Killer
Summary
This is easy to use no-mix formula, coming in a handy bottle with a convenient sprayer making it ready for use right out of the gate and simple to apply directly onto the precise spots you need. What’s not to love? Well, that very sprayer, while convenient, might cause some issues.
Water Resistance90
Selectiveness80
Speed90
Longevity70
Safety85
What We Like
No-mix formula
ready for use right away
Rainproof in only 10 minutes
Comes with a sprayer
What We Don't Like
The nozzle tends to clog and foam
Not safe for animals
Has no lasting prevention effects
83
Great

Key Features

Visible Results in 3 Hours

It kills the plants to the root, and within three hours of use you will already see them wilt before your very eyes!

Does not Spread Within The Soil

As a post-emergent product, this weed killer doesn’t remain in the ground and has no chance of killing the plants you want to keep alive.

Works on Almost all Weed Types

From bluegrass to ryegrass and beyond, this weedicide is able to kill almost any kind of weed on the spot!

No Mixing Required

Ready to use straight away requires no mixing or any other sort of preparation.

Easy to use: With a handy sprayer packed in, it has never been easier to target exactly the spots you want to work on and avoid the ones you don’t.

Customer Reviews

I had a couple of weeds growing through a rock bed close to the fire pit in my yard and my flower beds. This was just due to me doing some poor landscaping prep. One use of this product got rid of them, and I haven’t seen any trace of them since. I was incredibly concerned about killing the weeds in the flower bed while not damaging or killing my flowers accidentally, but this product has a great pinpoint sprayer nozzle which allowed me really focus the spraying and avoid hurting my plants. In the end, it was all a success, my flowers are safe, and the weeds are dead - big smiles all around. There’s just one small issue - it took a fair few days for it to actually kill the weeds thoroughly so it does take a bit of patience, but it does the job, ultimately. In the end, I am more than satisfied with this product.
Like other reviewers I have seen, I had some issues with the sprayer getting clogged or foaming, but the problem seemed to just disappear with time. It’s easily solvable by shaking the sprayer a bit, then holding down the button, and it works again. I used this on the weeds growing in my yard that selective herbicides simply didn’t work on. It’s easy to aim with the sprayer and focus on the weeds, limiting the amount of killed grass. It's a lengthy as well, and it's pretty easy to reach around shrubs and aim at the spot you want. Within three days of spraying, all the places I hit were completely dead. Even though I hope I won’t have to so, I would buy this weed killer again in a heartbeat.
A week after I bought it I used it to spray a large patch of many different weeds, pretty much every kind you can think of, and it did the job pretty good. Even after a couple of rainy days it still stuck. The amount I got covered far more ground than I expected and the attached handle worked well, so you get no complaints from me on that front.

Who Should Buy This Product

This is a handy product for people who don’t want a lot of hassle with a weed killer, especially beginners. No need to mix anything or follow complicated instructions, no need to use a different sprayer or anything of the sort – it comes with a sprayer of its own, and it’s ready to use right away.

What to Watch Out For

The sprayer itself is not the most well-made thing, and it has a tendency to clog and foam quite a lot, which might cause you some trouble out in the field and delay your work. Using a different sprayer might be a good idea.

The Conclusion

Decent product that’s not too expensive works on most weeds and is incredibly easy, able to be used by pretty much anybody. The sprayer that’s packed in also helps make things simpler and faster – unless it clogs that is, which happens way more than you’d expect. Still, it’s a genuinely good product that only needs a different sprayer to shine.

Spectracide Weed & Grass Killer
Summary
Simply a bargain, this product is easy to use out of the box and affordable to pretty much anybody, while killing a wide range of weeds. It's also perfectly safe for animals, which is something even some of the more expensive products don't offer. However, it doesn't kill everything, including some of the more common weeds, which limits its use.
Water Resistance85
Selectiveness70
Speed90
Longevity70
Safety95
What We Like
Completely safe for your pets and animals
Extremely low price
Covers a wide range of weeds
What We Don't Like
Hard to use
Doesn’t work on some of the more widespread weeds
The spray system is uncomfortable to use
82
Great

Key Features

Rainproof in only 15 Minutes

Only 15 minutes after application, the product is completely water resistant.

Safe for Your Pets

This product is made with pet owners and farmers in mind, and is perfectly safe for your animals.

Kills Plants Down to The Root

With its deep-acting formula, the roots are eradicated, ensuring that the weed won’t return.

Doesn’t Remain in The Soil

Your other plants will remain unaffected, and the soil is safe for planting after only a few hours.

Visible Results in 3 Hours

The plants will wither only three hours after application, guaranteed.

Customer Reviews

I was more than a little concerned about this herbicide as I didn’t know anything about the company that made. I still figured that I would try it out since the price was under 7 dollars. I’m glad I did, as I was pleasantly surprised. All the weeds vanished from my lawn only a few days after I used it. Sure, other products out there can do the same thing, but at twice or thrice the cost. Why waste all that cash if you get the same results with a cheaper product like this? I honestly don’t know.
I am incredibly pleased with this weed killer. The speed at which the weeds just died out is more than impressive. The spray nozzle is a pleasure to use. I applied this product at two houses I own, and it worked great in both places. I thought I made a grave mistake by spraying just before the rain hit, but it seems that has no effect whatsoever. The pricing is more than reasonable for what the product offers. The results were visible within a few hours, and it was very satisfying to see all those nasty weeds go brown. I would recommend this to pretty much anyone who needs a good weed killer for a decent price.
The weed problem I found myself in was immense after a bird feeder I had was demolished by some squirrels planting tons of unwanted plants all over my garden. This stuff solved that fast, however, as it killed pretty much everything within hours, not days like other products. It can also cover more than it seems at first, and after I treated three of my garden beds, I still have plenty left over if the weeds return.

Who Should Buy This Product

This is a very cheap product and is thus clearly suited for people on a budget that just need an affordable weed killer or people who simply don’t want to spend a lot of money. They will get their money’s worth with this product, for sure.

What to Watch Out For

While it works on most weeds, some of the more common troublesome plants like, for example, tumbleweed, are not something this product can deal with. Because of that, results might be inconsistent among users and even on a single property. Carefully read the list of weeds it works on before buying.

The Conclusion

This is a great product for the price and will do a lot of work for most people. If you’re on a budget, this might be the product of choice for you. Unless it doesn’t kill the weeds, you need it to kill – check the label before you buy. Otherwise, it’s good value for the price.

The Best Pick – Compare-N-Save Concentrate Grass and Weed Killer

With this much variety, it might be difficult to decide on the right product, and it all depends on what you need. Still, for us, the answer here is rather simple – the Compare-N-Save Concentrate Grass and Weed Killer wins hands down. Despite not offering something the other products too, the value here is just too difficult to pass up – with how much it costs, compared to the area it can cover, and the range of weeds it can kill with ease, the other weed killers in the roundup just can’t compare. It might be a bit harder to use, but it is more than worth it.

Video Review

The Conclusion

While that is our preferred product, the same might not be true for you – you might have a rather small property, and the other products might kill just the weeds you need, which is why you might opt for them. However, the winning product here seems to trump them all in the end, no matter what.

18 Comments

  1. Claire Giles
  2. Rebi
  3. Mincy
  4. Hari Priya
    • Semsem
  5. Rosemary
    • Pelli
  6. Dewey
  7. Abby
  8. Mara
  9. Grecy Garcia
  10. Trina P.
  11. Sean
  12. Sayle
  13. Hui Davis
  14. Michelle Valentine
  15. Dorothy
  16. Kalten

Reply

Cleaning Electricity and Wiring Flooring and Carpeting Heating and Cooling Home Appliances Pest Control
Hotel Rooms vs Corporate Apartments
The Differences Between Corporate Housing & Hotels
Kid Bedroom
6 Things That Should Be Found in Your Kid’s Bedroom
Building Architect in Vancouver
What’s the Difference Between an Architect vs Building Designer in Vancouver?
Container Gardening Flower Gardens Fruit Gardens Herb Gardens Ingredient Gardens Pest and Disease Control Vegetable Gardens
Pest Control Professional
Tips on What to Expect From a Termite Inspection
Indoor Gardening With LED Grow Lights
Can Indoor Gardening With LED Grow Lights Be Successful?
Peas Garlic Onions
Fall Gardening: The 3 Best Vegetables To Plant In The Fall Months
Lawn Care
Decorative Surface
How To Make Your Garden Look Unique
Automatic Sprinkler System
Basic Lawn Care and Maintenance Tips for a Healthy Lawn
Outdoor Fountain
Essential Guidelines for Caring for Outdoor Fountains